After lifelong best friends Hap and Leonard lose their jobs, a seductive figure from Hap's past resurfaces with a shadowy plan to score some major cash. Meanwhile, a menacing pair descends upon the duo’s hometown.
Enticed by Trudy, Hap and Leonard begin their search for the lost loot with new compatriots Howard, Chub and Paco. Leonard receives distressing news about his Uncle Chester.
Hap and Leonard find themselves under investigation for a crime they didn't commit, and their sharp new lawyer Florida Grange may be their only chance to set things right.
Hap and Florida scheme to free Leonard from a dire situation. At the local church, Hap ends up face-to-face with an unwelcome acquaintance from his past. Odd clues bring the guys to a cryptic person of interest in the case.
Hap begins to build a map of clues at the garage, while Leonard teaches Ivan some survival skills. Grisly new evidence leads the guys on a wild goose chase across town. Hap and Leonard's passions flare, threatening to derail the investigation.
Hap and Leonard deal with the repercussions of their crimes. Hanson and Charlie witness a suspicious incident at the morgue. Hap and Leonard split up to cover more ground and stumble upon the town's violent secret.
Hap and Leonard go undercover as carnival workers to investigate the endless supply of suspects. With the cops on their heels, they seek help from an unexpected ally to stop the culprit before another tragedy strikes.
Hap and Leonard cope with a series of goodbyes. This leads them to find a missing piece of the case hidden in plain sight. The investigation comes full circle, and the guys seek revenge for past transgressions.
Leonard lands in jail for burning down his neighbor's crack house. Hap agrees to go to Grovetown to look for a missing Florida Grange if Lt. Hanson will release Leonard.
After fleeing the Klan, Hap and Leonard become lost in a thicket outside Grovetown, where they discover Florida's abandoned car and find her tape recorder.
Hap and Leonard escape the Thicket and return to Grovetown more determined than ever to find Florida. However, before they can call Charlie for back up, Truman Brown's gang arrives, outnumbering and overpowering them.
Hap discovers a new clue about Florida's whereabouts and reconciles with Leonard. Officer Reynolds shows up unexpectedly with the FBI as the duo hatches a plan to return to Grovetown.