The girls are enjoying their night at Sweetheart's house. When bedtime comes, Patch tells a scary bedtime tale about a medieval Paradise Lake warrior named Squire, who failed his quest to tame the dragon Basil. The girls investigate the attic. The attic is dark and spooky but all they find is Sweethearts' cat Springfield. Back in the bedroom, Patch drifts off to sleep and sees the ghost of Squire who asks her to take care of some unfinished business. Episode Song: "Things Are Not Always What They Seem", sung by Patch.
Bon Bon's youngest baby brother catches the flu and Bon Bon begins to feel ingnored while her family cares for him. Bon Bon, upset by the lack of attention, pretends to be sick to get the attention she wants. She gets the attention but in the process puts her family in disarray. Soon Bon Bon confesses her bluff. Then the flu spreads to the entire family and Bon Bon gets more attention than ever before. Episode Song: "A Little Attention", sung by Bon Bon.
Melody and her Rockin' Beats band ready themselves for "The Battle of the Bands" competition, but Melody is responsible for the care of her baby sisters Jing-a-Ling and Ting-a-Ling. Unable to locate a babysitter, she is forced to take them with her to the band competition. Melody does her best to keep the twins out of her trouble while the Rockin' Beats band is struggling to do their job. Then Melody and the twins make an entrance onto the stage and the Rockin' Beats band wins the competition. Episode Song: "Sweet Music", First version sung by Melody and her band, The Rockin' Beats. Second version with Jing-a-Ling and Ting-a-Ling.
Clover dreams she wins the national Ponyland lotto. She finds her dream has come true the next morning and receives two winning tickets to the ball concert. The problem for Clover is to choose which one of her friends to take with her. In her attempt to please all of them she agrees to take each of them. They soon all realize they've been separately chosen and chase after Clover. To sort this out, Mr. Bloom picks two names at random and Clover and Melody are selected. Clover still feels guilty about going while the others watch them on TV, so Clover and Melody sell the tickets and buy pizza so they can join the other girls at home.
Melody brings her new cassette player to school, but accidentally leaves it behind in the school yard. After the cassette player goes missing, Melody and her friends strongly suspect Teddy of stealing it. The following day, a mock trial is held in the school classroom, with Teddy as the defendant and Bright Eyes as the prosecutor. Against Teddy's wishes, Sweetheart becomes his defense attorney, which prompts Melody to believe that Sweetheart has betrayed their gang. During the classroom trial, the witnesses and the class can provide no proof Teddy took the cassette player. Sweetheart eventually summons the school's custodian and it is revealed that he had found the cassette player and brought it to the Lost & Found. Sweetheart gets her cassette player back and Melody's attitude changes. Episode Song: "You Don't Know the Boy", sung by Sweetheart
While the girls are holding a tea party in an abandoned house, Starlight suggests that they allow boys in their club. The other members are initially reluctant, but after some discussion, decide to try it. After the club leaves the abandoned house, a family of new ponies arrive and remove the things the club has left behind. Thinking they are thieves, the girls set traps around the house. When the family arrives, they run into the traps. The girls soon realize that the new ponies are the Barrington family who are moving into the house. To make up for their mistake, the girls assist the Barringtons in maintaining the house. As a present, Mr. Barrington gets a clubhouse for the girls to use. Starlight invites Logan Barrington for some cookies at the next tea party. Episode Song: "Boys! Boys! Boys!", sung by all the girls.
As a reward for doing well on their tests, Ms. Hackney arranges a costume party for the class, where they dress up as what they would like to be when they grow up. Bon Bon has the idea of dressing up as a model but fears that she will be a laughing stock. She goes to the party, but as she enters, the other ponies roar with laughter at Patch's clown act. Thinking she's being mocked, Bon Bon runs away into the countryside. Teddy, who was the only one to catch sight of her, notifies the others and they go after her. They find her and convince her to come back to the party. She almost falls off a ledge, but they rescue her and they all go back to enjoy the party. Episode Song: "The Best Dream", sung by Bon Bon.
Clover's father searches the junkyard for pieces to use in his artwork and comes across a white teapot. Clover keeps the teapot, however, she soon begins to experience bad luck and believes the teapot is the cause of her misfortune. Every time Clover tries to get rid of the teapot, it somehow comes back to her and gets her in bigger trouble. She finally tells her father that she doesn't want it and he instead adds it to one of his art sculptures. Although Clover is finally rid the teapot she still feels haunted by it. Episode Song: "When Fortune Smiled On Me", sung by Clover.
All the of the class is going to perform in a theater a play on fairy tales. Melody has been picked to be the main role as the princess. Feeling full of herself, she bosses her family and even her friends, making them very cross with her. As payback, the girls spoil Melody's rehearsal in front of Teddy and Ace. After Starlight snaps at Melody about her current nature, this stirs Melody and a sudden realization hits her. Melody takes everything back and the performance runs smoothly. Episode Song: "The Magic of Theater", sung by Starlight.
Melody and Starlight share gossip with the other girls about their juicy stories, except for Sweetheart who doesn't like telling on others. Patch who tries to imagine Teddy and his secrets, assumes he has a teddy bear and the girls jeer. Ace overhears this and tells Lancer at football practice. They both poke fun at Teddy and he gives them a punch up and heads home. Teddy is mad at Sweetheart, who worsens his mood. To sort this out, Sweetheart forms a plan with her friends. Bright Eyes and Melody lure Ace and Lancer to babysit some baby ponies. They take good care of the babies but when feeding time comes, the girls force the two boys to eat and dress like babies and Sweetheart takes a picture of them which would ruin their reputation. In exchange for dropping the story of having a teddy bear, Teddy tears the photograph and is relieved his secret is safe and trusts Sweetheart more than before. Episode Song: "A Juicy Story", sung by all the girls.
Melody, Bright Eyes and Starlight are told that they are dating the rockstar Chain Link. It turns out Patch was imitating his voice on the phone and pulling a prank. For her next joke, Patch gets Bon Bon to do a quick cooking documentary, resulting in her cake getting burned. Using this film with some additional tricks, Patch sabotages Bright Eyes' school class project and turns it into a freak show. The girls decide to take action against Patch. Their amateur trick doesn't work on Patch and she continues to pull pranks on her friends. Suddenly Patch spots a flying saucer in the sky and finds some aliens where it lands. As the aliens declare that they want to remove her brain, she panics and backs away falling into a tub of water. This alien scene was set up by the girls with a little help from Teddy. Episode Song: "Practical Jokes", sung by Patch.
While teasing Bon Bon about her diary the girls accidentally break their only tea set. They have no money to buy a new one, so they raise some by making and selling lemonade. Jealous of their success, the boys try their own lemonade stall but don't know how to make good lemonade. Ace worms the recipe out of Bon Bon. Finding out that Ace has deceived Bon Bon, the girls and boys begin a rivalry to see whose better. Lancer settles the rivalry and decides to join up as well. They sell ice tea at the stall and Ace and Teddy walk off. Episode Song: "Think Again", sung by the girls at times and by the boys at times.
After throwing their picnic basket in the river, Teddy tries to convince Sweetheart he can be helpful and nice. He invites her to his cousin's farm. It is harvest time and the work runs smoothly. Teddy has trouble with the hens and the pig Yorkie. Yorkie tears Teddy's teddy bear so he gets mad and chases Yorkie into the country. Corny worries about Yorkie and while helping Yorkie falls and begins drowning in the river. Teddy who has never swum in running water before plucks up his courage and rescues Corny. At a Country Fair, Yorkie wins a 1st prize ribbon and Teddy wins a stuffed pig. He swaps the pig with Daisy for his teddy bear and feels happy. Episode Song: "It's Harvest Time", sung by the farming family.
Both Lancer and Bright Eyes want to ask each other to be partners in the upcoming roller derby, but are too shy to ask. Their friends try to help; Ace and Teddy encourage Lancer to act like a bad boy, while the girls suggest Bright Eyes act like an airheaded glamor girl. The two of one end up accidentally insulting each other, and walk off. On the day of the roller derby, the two explain what happened and make up. They then enter the derby together and win first place. Episode Song: "Play It Cool".
Patch tours her friends at the orphanage she once stayed and they help out in decorating the playground. The King and Queen are coming to find their long lost daughter here. The description resembles Patch and she finds on her hoof a birth mark which was not here before. The girls dress Patch up as a princess and Patch feels very gloomy about leaving her adopted parents and her friends and staying in a castle. The King and Queen don't manage to find their daughter. Patch notices that the birthmark on her hoof is actually some paint spilled from the decorating. By the time she realises Rosy is the royal ponies' missing daughter, they are leaving. Patch stops them and brings Rosy to them. Episode Song: "A Princess Must Look Beautiful".
Ms. Hackney gets a headache and leaves the teaching to Starlight. She has to teach them about the prehistoric cave ponies of Pinto Cave and how a pulley works. The class are not taking their studies seriously, much to Starlight's chagrin. Starlight tries again and takes them on field trip to Pinto Cave. The class enters Pinto Cave, into a cavern where the cave ponies once stored their tools. To get out of the cave, Ace attaches a pulley to the cave ceiling and hoists all the ponies up. They return to school and Ms. Hackney is proud of Starlight and gives her an apple. Episode Song: "Lessons", sung by Starlight, Bright Eyes and Sweetheart.
A UFO has been sighted in the mountains. The police won't allow anyone to get close. Mr. Kiddoo comes to show the class the hot air balloon. Patch takes the opportunity to get in the balloon followed by a reluctant Bon Bon. The balloon takes off and Patch and Bon Bon find themselves high in the sky. Suddenly they are attacked by birds and the balloon is falling into some shark infested waters. Bon Bon can't bear to look and Patch sees the UFO turns into Flying Glowing Magic Ponies. The leader of the group, Dazzleglow (a pony with a pair of wings and a horn), rescues them and brings them to safety. Patch is in trouble but goes to the peak of the mountain to find out more but Patch isn't ready to know and may meet the Glow n' Show Ponies once more. Episode Song: "The Adventure", sung by Patch.
Clover's sister Meadowlark is going to marry the handsome pony Cheval. Clover and her friends help prepare for the wedding. They are assigned to pick up the rings, the flowers and the cake. Not everything goes well because the flowers are ruined, Clover manages to tumble into the wedding cake and lose the rings, and the girls spot Meadowlark's fiancée flattering an unknown female pony whom the girls believe he wants to marry instead. The female pony that Cheval was talking to turns out to be his sister (so naturally he has no interest in marrying her). There are also plenty of flowers in Clover's family's garden that they use for the wedding, Bon Bon fixes the ruined wedding cake and the rings are found so the wedding commences. Episode Song: "Today's My Wedding Day", sung by Meadowlark.
Bright Eyes reads about an endangered bird called the Green-Winged Song Bird. Bright Eyes, Ace, Bon Bon and Patch explore the forest to find out why the bird is endangered. Along the journey, they get stung by nettles, covered in mud, chased by bees and eventually get hungry. They catch a fish, but are too sympathetic to eat him and put him back in the river. As their hopes go down, they see a Green-Winged Song Bird and find out that they have become endangered due to the logging of trees they live on. With the help of directions Bon Bon wrote in her diary, they make it back to town. Bright Eyes tells about her findings and is declared by the mayor as Pony Of The Month. Episode Song: "In the Forest", sung by Bright Eyes.
Clover's sister Meadowlark comes to town. Clover starts feeling overshadowed by Meadowlark's superior talent. When the Harlequin in the upcoming ballet recital is injured, Clover takes her place. Overcome with nervousness, Clover pretends to have amnesia. Sensing her sister's stage fright, Meadowlark confesses to Clover that she was the same on her first performance. On the night of the recital, Clover plucks up the courage to play her part and performs brilliantly, to the applause of the crowd and her family. Episode Song: "She's So Much Better Than Me", sung by Clover.
The girls practice their swimming routine at Lancer's mansion for an upcoming contest, but Teddy's pranks ruin their outcome at the Swimming Gala. Angrily, the girls demand that Sweetheart uninvite Teddy from her upcoming birthday party, giving the choice "him or us". Not wanting to choose between them, Sweetheart calls the party off. To sort it all out Lancer tricks both Teddy and the girls into getting on his father's yacht, refusing to let them off until they sign a peace treaty and Lancer convinces them to put their differences aside for Sweetheart. Lancer then brings Sweetheart to his mansion, where everyone surprises her with the party. Episode Song: "An Unforgettable Party", sung by Sweetheart's friends.
When the girl's picnic is rained out, Sweetheart finds a frog with an injured leg. Sweetheart takes the frog (she named Spot) to the vet who tells Sweetheart he'll be well in 3 days. Sweetheart takes him with her but causes trouble at Bon Bon's house and Starlight's ice cream parlor. Sweetheart brings Spot to school, but he causes more chaos. Miss Hackney tells Sweetheart to set Spot free. Tearfully, the girls release Spot into the wild. Episode Song: "Off You Go", sung by Sweetheart. Episode Song: "An Unforgettable Party", sung by Sweetheart's friends.
Bon Bon forgets to study for her math test, so she cheats and gets away with it, but she gets disappointed from her lack of skill. She forgets to take the diary with her and Teddy takes it. Teddy comes up to Bon Bon and threatens to show off the diary if she doesn't come with him to the ball concert. Bon Bon calls Sweetheart to sort out the problem and she calls Teddy and tells him what keeping personal secrets is about. Teddy hands the diary to Ms. Hackney. Bon Bon confesses that she cheated to get an 'A' and Ms. Hackney gives her diary back. After taking a resit, Bon Bon gets a 'C', but Teddy flunks his test and Bon Bon offers to study with him so they can pass the next test before going to the ball concert. Episode Song: "Secrets", sung by the girls.
Starlight is in love with Ace, but he doesn't share the same feelings for her and takes no notice of her. Starlight joins the soccer team to win his heart. Ace humiliates her in front of the team and Starlight is ready to quit, but Patch convinces her to stay on the team for the upcoming soccer match. In this match Starlight scores a magnificent goal that settles the game and leads her team to victory, making Ace jealous instead of impressed. Ace comes around and talks to Starlight and accepts her as a member of the team and praises her goal. Episode Song: "Perfect Pair", sung by Starlight and divided into two parts.
Bright Eyes is going on an exchange trip to the Tropical Island. Her friends have rumours that the island has a sea monster, the inhabitants are savages that cannibalise and sacrifice little girls to the volcano. Bright Eyes dismisses those ideas and goes to the island where she stays with Sunbright family. Bright Eyes' fear of the superstitions is declared when the Sunbrights take her for a hike to the volcano. The Sunbrights rescue Bright Eyes from the crater. After that Bright Eyes experiences more fun and activities with Moki. Episode Song: "We May Be Different...", sung by Bright Eyes and Moki.
Bright Eyes brings to her friends' attention the current garbage pollution problem. They divide into teams to track down the responsible dumpers but they are not using their common sense and do their own littering. As a result Pony River gets clogged and floods the surface. Whilst the grownups unclog the river, the girls see the trash they threw previously and fully realise their carelessness and begin cleaning up. Episode Song: "A Lot Less Litter", sung by the girls.