While the girls are holding a tea party in an abandoned house, Starlight suggests that they allow boys in their club. The other members are initially reluctant, but after some discussion, decide to try it. After the club leaves the abandoned house, a family of new ponies arrive and remove the things the club has left behind. Thinking they are thieves, the girls set traps around the house. When the family arrives, they run into the traps. The girls soon realize that the new ponies are the Barrington family who are moving into the house. To make up for their mistake, the girls assist the Barringtons in maintaining the house. As a present, Mr. Barrington gets a clubhouse for the girls to use. Starlight invites Logan Barrington for some cookies at the next tea party. Episode Song: "Boys! Boys! Boys!", sung by all the girls.