Clover dreams she wins the national Ponyland lotto. She finds her dream has come true the next morning and receives two winning tickets to the ball concert. The problem for Clover is to choose which one of her friends to take with her. In her attempt to please all of them she agrees to take each of them. They soon all realize they've been separately chosen and chase after Clover. To sort this out, Mr. Bloom picks two names at random and Clover and Melody are selected. Clover still feels guilty about going while the others watch them on TV, so Clover and Melody sell the tickets and buy pizza so they can join the other girls at home.