Joe Silva, a down on his luck fisherman, must contend with his overbearing father, his ex-wife who has recently returned to Provincetown, and Captain Dory Pearl Souza PhD, who recently bought his fishing boat. Meanwhile the discovery of a hanged woman's body over Commercial Street begins a series of events that will reverberate though town.
Chord O'Cleary makes a shocking discovery on the beach that further complicates matters. Christian poet, Chris Christofferson, befriends Ivan Zamir, a Wall Street investor, who was sent to hide in Provincetown. Joe get arrested. Maya and Rosie discuss the hanged woman.
While in jail, Joe is visited by his dad, Gusty, his ex-wife Doris, and Capt. Dory Pearl Souza, who makes him an offer. Doris gets some bad news. Margarita investigates the suicide.
Maya is threatened by one of her yoga students, and gets some bad news from Rosie. Tony gets a call with some odd information regarding "The Wig in the Water".
Chord questions Tony about Joe's possible involvement in the death of Linc Standish. Ivan gets some bad news. Joe and Dory get friendly.
Tony goes to the police station to share information regarding the wig. Olga has a flashback that reveals the Standish/Silva feud. Tony has an art opening that ends in chaos.
May and Margarita continue to play "cat and mouse". Olga meets Celeste, a new coworker. Margarita tires to recruit Pilar into her "pill scheme". Dian meets Bobby for lunch with a surprise proposal. Joe meets Chris.
Tony has an encounter with a stranger. Joe and Dory's relationship takes a turn. Dian becomes increasingly desperate.
Maya takes drastic action. Ivan and Margarita perform a "coup". Tony and Dean's relationship deepens. A fishing trip on Blue Skies erupts into chaos. Olga has an awakening. Gusty gives Doris a surprising proposal.
Dory and Detective Meads have a chat. Margarita overhears some surprising news. Maya makes a confession. Joe and Dory's relationship takes a turn. Chord visits Tony as he recovers. Joe pays a late night visit to Doris.
Maya gets a surprise at the yoga studio. Chords new "honesty" policy gets him in trouble. Doris gives Joe some shocking news. Ivan and Margarita get in a row over La Morada. Ivan and Bobby go to visit Dianne and share stories of past loves. Joe confronts Gusty, after which he confines in Tony. Doris and Joe hatch a "crazy" plan. Chris returns to town with his pregnant wife Sterling.
Maya and Margarita recover after a shocking night. Ivan gets some surprising news. Dot helps Bobby one to terms with his past. Tony and Dean run into an old friend. Det. Meads plays Dory visit. A surprise winter storm bears down on Provincetown causing pa town wide power failure.
The women at La Morada are confronted with multiple surprises. Bobby and Ivan clash over work at The Good Egg. Doris tells Joe she having second thoughts about their plan. Tony and Dean discuss "last night". Joe gets bad news.
Chord has his art opening with mixed results. Ivan has some news for Tony. Maya and Margarita meet for dinner. Doris is troubled by current events. Tony confronts Joe about his future.