Connect Four

Die Heffernans haben das Problem, dass sie kein Paar finden, mit dem beide harmonieren. Doug mag den Mann von Carries Spinning-Freundin nicht, und Carrie mag die Freundin von Dougs Freund nicht. Carrie hat die Idee die kriselnde Beziehungen der beiden Paare für ihre Zwecke zu nutzen.

Carrie wins 4 company seats to Knicks games, but insists on taking a couple over Doug's friends. But when they realize Carrie's favored couple doesn't work for Doug, and Doug's favored couple doesn't work for Carrie, they decide on playing cupid. Meanwhile, Arthur digs himself a hole by pretending he can "fix" parking tickets.

Mentre cercano la coppia perfetta con cui uscire, Doug e Carrie causano la separazione fra Elly e Stuart, e la fine della relazione fra Eddie e Simone.

Carrie og Doug har fået fire billetter til alle Knicks kampe i en måned, og prøver derfor at finde ud af hvilket par, der skal gøre dem selskab til kampene.