While touring a museum, Garfield and Odie accidentally touch an idol that exchanges minds to anyone who touches it. / Orson tries to pick a book to read to Sheldon and Booker, eventually choosing Cinderella. Sheldon and Booker decide to change bits of the story, since they complain that this is a girl's story. / Garfield, Jon, and Odie travel to an out-of-the-way Italian restaurant which serves, in Garfield's recollection, the best Italian food he has ever eaten. He also finds that a large chain of pizzerias, Papa Plastique, whose food is so bad even Garfield wouldn't eat them, wants to buy Mama Manicotti's recipes.