Game 1: Mrs. Norma Walker - ""Mayor"" (from Aurora, CO, she is their first woman mayor; they have a population of 65,000 and are the 4th largest city in Colorado; she ran on a non-partisan ticket, but Bennett discovered she was a Democrat) Game 2: Jim Koane - ""Makes Flag Poles"" (he is the Assistant Vice-President of American Flag Pole Company; from West Islip, Long Island, NY) Game 3: Maureen O'Sullivan (as Mystery Guest) She promoted her Broadway play: ""The Subject Was Roses"" Game 4: Miss Jean Herrschoft ""Men's Barber"" (at Andre's Barber Shop in Greenlawn, Long Island, NY; from Centereach, NY; Arlene asks her, ""Are they still wearing the long hair cuts?"")
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maureen O'Sullivan | Guest Star |