Game 1: Gloria Shiner Williams - ""Sheep and Goat Rancher"" (from Bandera, Texas) Game 2: John Halloran - ""Private Detective (85 Years Old)"" (from Grand Rapids, Michigan) Private Detective Game 3: The McGuire Sisters (as Mystery Guest Trio) Christine, born July 30, 1926; Dorothy, born February 13, 1928; Phyllis, born February 14, 1931