Game 1: Jim Piersall (as Mystery Guest #1 and the panel was blindfolded) - ""Center Fielder, Boston Red Sox"" (salaried) Game 2: Miss Esther Clair - ""Sells Horse and Dog Medicine"" (salaried; she works for Zarin Industries and sells a vitamin syrup; her employer's clients include Calumet Farms; from Miami, FL, where she won the title of ""Miss Miami Beach 1954"") Game 3: Paul Douglas (as Mystery Guest #2)