Game 1: Bette Lucas - ""Bartender"" (at The Old Stone Inn; from Trenton, NJ Game 2: Dorothy Bernard - ""Sells Horse Meat"" (no home town given) Game 3: Oscar Hammerstein II (as Mystery Guest) Game 4: Hubert Groves - ""Sells Axes and Hatchets"" (from Dallas, TX)
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oscar Hammerstein II | Guest Star |