Phil and Leo prank Dean. Dawn is determined to not let anything ruin her night. Mark challenges Grace.
Nancy and Ben engage in a phone tag fight while Mark reveals who he's setting Grace up with. Clean Gene multitasks by manhandling Pedro and talking with Mark. Mr. Abramson arrives for his midnight therapy session with Mrs. Abramson hot on his heels.
Nancy threatens to 'big L' leave Ben as their fight escalates. Dawn, Phil and Leo discover they aren't alone. Nancy scares Dean Blackman and sidesteps his suspicions. Mr. Abramson surprises Mark when he reveals why things aren't working with Mrs. A.
Mark and Mr. Abramson manage to stir things up in time for Mrs. Abramson to interrupt. Grace attempts to seduce Gene.
Dean Blackman and Dawn succumb to passion as Phil, Leo and Ben are trapped. Grace gets Gene talking about her two favorite things: murder and sex. Phil and Leo turn the tables on Dean Blackman.
Grace gets a taste of life with a hit man when Nancy shows up at her door. Still angry from her fight with Ben, Nancy confides in Gene and Grace. Grace convinces her they should call Mark, the Midnight Therapist, for advice.
Mr. Abramson and Mark are interrupted, this time by Grace, Gene and Nancy. Pedro arrives on the scene having tracked down Mr. Abramson. It flusters Gene and chaos ensues. Nancy tells everyone the story and a debate begins over Ben's sexuality.
Nancy and the gang ambush Ben for an impromptu therapy session with Mark, the Midnight Therapist. Will their love survive? Will Gene and Grace finally do it? Can Dean Blackman trust Dawn again? Mark's skills are put to the test.