Billie and Aidan jump through hoops to find each other the perfect gift after learning their birthdays are only three days apart. Three days and 10 years, that is. Billie winds up selecting dozens of possible gifts; and to make things worse, Billie's ex Lewis seems to have come up with the ultimate present for her -- an expensive bracelet, which Billie and Cheryl assume, came from Aidan. Meanwhile, Aidan panics when Ed derides his impulsive ""perfect"" gift for Billie: a blue catcher's mitt.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rich Kaplan | Writer | ||
| Reginald C. Hayes | Guest Star | ||
| Mark Cendrowski | Director |