As Jim and Nugget have their sardines for snack, Mrs. Bevan shows up and waves a town-hall decree: sardines consumption is strictly forbidden from now on! It smells too bad! The pirates and Matilda then open “The Underground Sardine”, a restaurant specialized in pirate food! One by one, the villagers of Dull-on-Sea comes to the restaurant to taste pirate cooking, and to have fun! Mrs. Bevan and the Winners attempt to discover why the entire city stinks of sardine… Jim and Matilda will have to be smarter to keep eating pirate food!