Michael finally finds out the truth about why Vanessa left him. He realizes that Tyus must have been trying to treat Vanessa's illness. Meanwhile, Tyus and Vanessa are analyzing the position they were in before. Although they both agree that they would never do something like this even if they were sober, Vanessa warns him that she though he was Michael, and she isn't sure if they stopped in time. Ben tells Meg that he knows that she slept with Derek, and she begs for his forgiveness. He tells her that he doesn't hold her responsible, and reassures her that their love will be enough to get them through the difficulties caused by Derek. Olivia says that she wouldn't let Trey go -- not this time. Nearly everyone at the baptism believes Olivia has flipped her lid. Sean convinces Olivia to give Trey back to Caitlin. Olivia bolts from the church, and Antonio finishes up the baptism. Caitlin blames herself for Olivia's breakdown. Olivia realizes that it's more painful to know the truth about what happened to her baby.