Lucy tries to put Ian at ease by assuring him that her kiss was only an attempt to reestablish contact with her missing husband. As they search the woods for Rebecca's candle, Jack admits to Alison how his trip the cabin ended. Noting how uneasy Rafe seems in close proximity to her, Livvie embroiders on her original lie with stories about how comfortable they have always been together as lovers. While visiting his wife's grave, Ian is surprised to bump into Alison's attorney. Rafe asks Livvie to be patient with him as he struggles to recover the memory of their ""storybook"" romance. Lucy explains to Jack and Alison why she brought Rebecca's portrait back to her place. Ian advises Kate to keep an open mind as she builds her case for the defense. Later, however, Kate rolls her eyes in disgust when Alison reveals how Ian channeled Kevin so he could deliver a message to Lucy. Jack shows a nervous Livvie the chain her new man dropped at the cabin.