Magicians Jandro, Piff the Magic Dragon, Helen Coghlan, and Paul Gertner try to fool the veteran duo with their illusions.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alyson Hannigan | Producer | ||
| Danny Harris | Producer | ||
| Jandro | Guest Star | Self - Magician | |
| Piff the Magic Dragon | Guest Star | ||
| Fernando Acevedo | Guest Star | The Spanish Penn | |
| Penn Jillette | Executive Producer | ||
| Teller | Executive Producer | ||
| Lincoln D. Hiatt | Executive Producer | ||
| Peter Adam Golden | Executive Producer | ||
| Glenn S. Alai | Executive Producer | Co-Executive Producer | |
| Andrew J. Golder | Executive Producer | ||
| Dennis Rosenblatt | Director |