When a seller brings an E.T. printer's proof movie poster into the shop, Chum phones his resident expert for advice. Will he be able to make an out of this world deal? Then, Rick and Corey take a Civil War rifle out to the range. Will they see double when the seller tries to make an offer? After, Rick investigates a dog shaped diamond, but will the deal be all bark and no bite? And later, is it a bird? Is it a plane? It's a Superman pinback! Can Chum save the day, or will the deal go "up, up, and away?"