Jen considers leaving town because Daniel is back from his honeymoon and she is worried he might arrest her. Daniel has a flashback of the night he killed Paul Cramer. John meets Evangeline's family and a ex-boyfriend of hers, who don't believe that John is the right choice for their 'Cookie'. Marcie gives Todd a piece of her mind because of the story he published about The Killing Club murders.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Janet Hubert | Guest Star | ||
| Michael Early | Guest Star | ||
| Steve Wood | Guest Star | ||
| Obba Babatundé | Guest Star |