A game of peekaboo ends with Rogers presenting a portrait of his father, painted by Dianne Dengle. She has asked Mister Rogers to pose for his own portrait, which she paints with bits of rolled-up newspaper. The Neighborhood of Make-Believe welcomes James Michael Jones, a specialist in "Exactly Like Me" portraits (mirrors). Jones announces that he is moving to Southwood, where he will marry Betty Okonak Templeton.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fred Rogers | Writer | ||
| Dianne Dengle | Guest Star | ||
| Paul Lally | Director |