In a carnival, Annie sees a game called the great Schubert's guessing game. The game quizzes Annie on which of the four rides in the carnival (bumper cars, merry go round, slide and roller coaster) is Schubert's favorite, and the prize is a stuffed horse which is her favorite animal. Schubert gives Annie three musical clues to know which is the right one, though a gust of wind blows them around the carnival, and it is up to the team to find all three before the game runs out of time.