It's Christmas time and Jack throws his annual party at the office. He dresses up as Santa, and tells Elliot's nephew that he won't get any presents for being a naughty boy and pushing Hannah out of the line. When Jack finds out the truth that Hannah made it up because she thinks she can do anything and her daddy owns the world, he has to apologize to little Paul, but only make things worse. Meanwhile, Kevin's cousin Ray Liotta attends the party and sparks fly between him and Maya. But Ray's odd obsession with Christmas scares her away. And Finch and Nina fight over who creates the best new Christmas song. They can't come up with anything so they decide to become Jewish.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brett Baer | Writer | ||
| David Finkel | Writer | ||
| Robert Reins | Guest Star | ||
| Nathan Norton | Guest Star | ||
| Jenna Boyd | Guest Star | ||
| Ed Gale | Guest Star | ||
| Arturo Gil | Guest Star | ||
| Ray Liotta | Guest Star | ||
| Pamela Fryman | Director |