Jamie (Jack Tracy) jumps right out of a five year relationship into the arms of Joshua (Scott Mandel). Long time friends Bianca (Bianca Lyn) and Catherine (Carissa Fales) grow concerned
Jamie (Jack Tracy) throws himself back into the dating world, while also calling on an old hookup (Mike Longo). But the emotional impact of the recent breakup forces him to understand his impulse to engage in no strings sex.
Jamie (Jack Tracy) starts new friendships, meeting Matthew (Jacob Seidman) and Gio (Rob Maitner) at a Pride party, and steers his relationship with William (Will Cohen) to friendship. But when Jamie meets Matthew's friend circle, he finds Brian's (Cameron Moir) treatment of his boyfriend disgusting, yet familiar.
Jamie (Jack Tracy) skirts William's (Will Cohen) questions about his old friend group and apartment move. After William explains his view of friendships, Jamie makes a choice.
Jamie (Jack Tracy) brings William (Will Cohen) and Matthew (Jacob Seidman) to Ted's (Trent Stone) RuPaul's Drag Race viewing party. In the midst of Jamie's struggle over whether he can be the "top" in a relationship, William's Grindr profile hits a sore spot.
When Jamie (Jack Tracy) and Jared (Andrew Lipson) end up on the same train, Jamie seeks advice from his friends on what to do, and answers to why he's still so angry.
One year later, Jamie rekindles his relationship with Collin and attempts to smooth over recent stress in his friendship with William. William and Matthew both reveal new love interests to the group.
Despite his recent reuniting with Collin, Jamie finds himself courted by Stephen, whose confession forces Jamie to overcome a long held fear.
Jamie grows increasingly irritated with Kyle and the gay community's obsession with social media, in general. Collin and Stephen confess their feelings.
William urges Jamie to make a call between Collin and Stephen, just before their own friendship crumbles.
When Jamie pokes his head up from his romantic life, he finds his friends becoming more and more irritated with him. Gio puts on a cabaret.
Jamie considers entering into a new relationship and decides whether to leave yet another friendship in the past.
One year later, Jamie, Will and Matthew are all in relationships. Jamie's mother comes to town for a visit and triggers concern with a passing comment.
Jamie gets surprising news from his sister and heads with the boys to visit Mack at Penn State. Mack's behavior and appearance cause concern.
Jamie's plans to confront Mack on his behavioral changes are blown up leading to a rift. The boys go on their cabin retreat and Mark reminds Jamie of Brandon's "expectation."
Jamie instantly dislikes Kevin's rude work friend at a house party, but is kept from putting him in his place. Will asks for advice and Jamie recalls the inciting incident of his split with Jared.
Following Kevin's party, Jamie finds himself back in therapy while Will uncovers why he isn't "all in" with Kevin.
Jamie and Will head to Jamie's childhood home for a family gathering and confronts his mother.