A substitute teacher filling in for Miss Sherwood tries to keep her past as a singer a secret, but Dwight remembers her from his childhood and is determined to find out why she stopped singing, enlisting Mr. Shorofsky's help when he learns the truth.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Melissa Manchester | Guest Star | ||
| Seth Kaufman | Guest Star | ||
| Robert Scheerer | Director |