Will Dan let Keith have his happily ever after? And are we in support?! As the Queens realize that the start of Nathan and Haley's relationship mirrors Jules and Keith's, we wonder why we root for certain characters and perhaps not others? As Hilarie, Sophia, and Joy discuss Keith, they begin to reminisce about Craig Sheffer. The ladies confirm that just like Barry Corbin and Paul Johansson, he was an amazing mentor, protector, and costar. And Craig is here to join the Drama Queens. The girls have butterflies, and QUESTIONS! For one, how did onscreen enemies Dan and Keith become BFFs IRL? Plus, the name of the game is always (early 2000s) fashion, and Haley's tour style is a-changing! So we must discuss the looks! And the mess Chris Keller keeps trying to make of her life! Last but not least, Peyton and Jake have what may be the steamiest show on OTH to date. And Hilarie, we need to know everything.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hilarie Burton | Host | Host | |
| Sophia Bush | Host | Host | |
| Bethany Joy Lenz | Host | Host | |
| Craig Sheffer | Guest Star | Guest |