Gina follows who she thinks is Celeste into the church and ends up being knocked over the head with a book by the desecrator. When Caroline, John and Kristen go to decorate the church, they find Gina unconscious on the floor and the church spray-painted. Marlena rushes to the church because Abe called her for the psychological profile of the person doing the crimes. Caroline wonders if the desecrator could be someone they know. Lexie says Jonah's been avoiding her ever since he kissed her at the gym. Jonah doesn't want to discuss it and promises it will never happen again. Lexie says they have to get over it and act normal again around each other. Wendy shops for gifts for Benjamin's godfathers, Austin and Jonah. Maggie tells Wendy that Jonah is great with Benjamin. Mike reminisces about his loved ones and tells Mickey he has a surprise for Alice. Jack asks Alice for help in getting back Jennifer, wanting to break up Jennifer and ìthat block of iceî (Peter). He tells her ìMonicaî helped bring out feelings in him he's never had before. Jack disappears when Jennifer and Laura drop by. Everyone gathers at Salem Place for the second lighting of the Christmas tree. Jack has dressed up as Santa to get closer to Abigail. Abe tells his officer on duty, Detective Adams, that the password is ìSantaî and the desecrator overhears. The desecrator gets him to leave and opens the Christmas tree fuse box.