Michelle Kwan is presenting the Athlete of the Year Award, and Jenna wins the award, which makes Francine very jealous and upset. With the help of Muffy, Francine tries to prove that she deserves the award by pretending to act like a good sport and giving Jenna special attention, but nothing works. Arthur develops a crush on his new babysitter, Sally, after playing a video game with her. He is devastated when he discovers that she has a boyfriend and refuses to see her again. However, when Buster invites Arthur over for a sleepover, Arthur discovers that Sally is babysitting for Buster. She tells Arthur that she enjoys playing video games more with him as her boyfriend is not good at video games.