D.W. wants to prove to Arthur that she can tell a good story, and, after getting advice from Grandma Thora, retells the Odyssey in her own way. Prunella gets two dolls for her birthday and dismisses the second one, which is from Francine. Later, Prunella thinks that Francine spoiled the party by not joining in on the festivities. That night, Prunella has a dream where the Ghost of Presents Past takes her through time to clear things up and shows how far Francine went to get the doll for Prunella and makes her realize that Francine's attitude was because of how Prunella did not appreciate the present.