Andy is hired to follow a woman's stepmother and find out if she is having an affair. While trying to solve that case, he is instructed by his wife to investigate the disappearance of their daughter's favorite toy. Molly is incapable of sleeping without the stuffed elephant, Snowball and Jenny wants the toy back.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jonathan Groff | Writer | ||
| Conan O'Brien | Writer | ||
| Shane Baumel | Guest Star | ||
| J. Robin Miller | Guest Star | ||
| Kenneth Beck | Guest Star | ||
| Sarah Christine Smith | Guest Star | ||
| Nestor Carbonell | Guest Star | ||
| Maribeth Monroe | Guest Star | ||
| Marie Lyn Deja | Guest Star | ||
| Desi Jevon | Guest Star | ||
| Krizia Bajos | Guest Star | ||
| Marcus Folmar | Guest Star | ||
| Jesse L. Martin | Guest Star | ||
| Jason Ensler | Director |