A surprise getaway for a camping trip to Catalina Island leads to the first helicopter ride for the Amish, a close encounter with a group of dolphins and a parasailing adventure, but while the idyllic setting allows two of the roommates to momentarily cool their ongoing feud, conflicts erupt between several of the others. Meanwhile, the beach, the ocean and the moonlight provide the perfect backdrop for Nick and Ariel to sneak away for some quality romance time together, but soon discover they are not alone. Later, when the gang returns from their trip, a heated argument with Meagan causes the typically quiet Randy to lose his cool.