A couple dares to spend a night in one of the most infamous haunted houses.
| Name | Type | Role | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brad Falchuk | Writer | ||
| Ryan Murphy | Writer | ||
| Tom Lenk | Guest Star | Tim Williams | |
| Jackson Unvert | Guest Star | Redhead Trick-or-treater #2 | |
| Harrison Xu | Guest Star | William | |
| Noah Cyrus | Guest Star | Connie | |
| Kimberly Cheng | Guest Star | Reporter | |
| Selena Sloan | Guest Star | Erin | |
| Dylan McDermott | Guest Star | Dr. Ben Harmon | |
| Sierra McCormick | Guest Star | Scarlett Winslow | |
| Efrangeliz Medina | Guest Star | Janna | |
| Adam Hagenbuch | Guest Star | Dylan | |
| David St. James | Guest Star | Neighbor | |
| Ashley Martin Carter | Guest Star | Rowena | |
| Paris Jackson | Guest Star | Maya | |
| Kaia Gerber | Guest Star | Ruby McDaniel | |
| Angela Halili | Guest Star | Kate | |
| Jamie Brewer | Guest Star | Adelaide 'Addy' Langdon | |
| Shane Carpenter | Guest Star | Infantata | |
| Valerie Loo | Guest Star | Nicole | |
| Merrin Dungey | Guest Star | Dr. Andi Grant | |
| John Brotherton | Guest Star | Steven | |
| Tabitha Petrini | Guest Star | Mika | |
| Nicolas Bechtel | Guest Star | Rory | |
| Luke Sonderman | Guest Star | Redhead Trick-or-treater #1 | |
| Kelly Róisín | Guest Star | Nurse Gladys | |
| Mercedes Mason | Guest Star | Michelle | |
| Aaron Coleman | Guest Star | Driver | |
| Liz Friedlander | Director |