Eileen Rodgers--""Third(3rd) Finger-Left Hand."" THE AMERICAN BANDSTAND TOP TEN of 9/25/1957: 1. The Crickets-That'll Be the Day 2. Debbie Reynolds-Tammy 3. Paul Anka-Diana 4. Jimmie Rodgers-Honeycomb 5. Jerry Lee Lewis-Whole Lot of Shakin' Going on 6. Elvis Presley-(Let Me Be Your) Teddy Bear 7. The Bobbettes-Mr. Lee 8. Billy Williams-I'm Gonna Sit Right Down and Write Myself A Letter 9. Tony Bennett-In the Middle of an Island 10. Pat Boone-Remember You're Mine.