Bucks's dare takes a turn for the worse when his lacrosse teammates trick him into burglarizing his coach's house.
The future of Brooke and Adam's relationship is called into question when Bucks proposes a bold truth. Their conflicting responses create a state of shear discomfort at the bonfire.
Elizabeth probes Cara to admit to her deep-rooted truth regarding her sexuality. The group becomes wary of Elizabeth's motives, as Cara relives the suppressed events of her traumatic past.
The tension at the bonfire reaches new heights when Elizabeth confidently accepts Cara's challenge. An inevitable showdown between the two interrupts the completion of the dare.
It's nearing the 48th hour since Elizabeth's disappearance. The group begins to lose hope, but Bucks persists in his arduous search. When Bucks returns with telling evidence, Adam takes a stand against Brooke.
After three weeks of coming up empty-handed, Adam and Bucks are still as determined as ever to canvas the entire town in search for Elizabeth. The boys come impeccably close to discovering the threatening reality of Elizabeth's whereabouts.