This is an alternate version of "Spider" with several scenes shortened and Skillet's drum solo added in. Rhoda and Shark's conversation is cut down, thus removing Golden Joe's appearance, Mosquitor's letter was cut down and the dripping blood was removed, and Shark's conversation with Fitz about the record is shortened to "Don't look under your bed." These cuts made room for an extended drum solo which went on for several minutes. This special aired directly following the premiere of the standard version of "Spider."
The Eye's surgery was a success, and he joins his twin in tap-dancing. Liquor manages to trap the hand attacking the Cop and Golden Joe in a jar. Meanwhile, the Spider brings Roostre to a cave in the desert and plays on the piano "Booger Haze", summoning thousands of musical notes that attack Mouse and Skillet. Eventually they find protection in Roostre's secret ammo hold.
Mouse catches a glimpse of the real world at the Q-109 headquarters after seeing a singing spirit named Archaeus. The people who act as Shark and Rectangular Businessman get killed by the people acting as Peanut Cop and the Annoying Lady. Mouse fades back into the real world and realizes it has been reset, and that as 2:23 reaches, Mouse, Peanut, and Golden Joe realize that everything is gonna be okay.
Mouse, Skillet, Golden Joe and Peanut Cop trek through the desert after leaving the city behind. However, Golden Joe is carried away by a bird and Peanut Cop later vanishes in a flash of light. Now alone in the desert, Fitz and Skillet live in a house made of sand and their own spit. They get into a gunfight with a strange, gun-toting woman named Lee. After the woman mentions something about Square Guy and finding the new angel (or "new age-el") Fitz decides to trust her and invites her into his house. Lee gives Fitz a gift: a silver bullet which she warns is the only thing that can kill her when she turns into the She-Wolf. After the credits, a gunshot is heard, and Lee (as the She-Wolf) appears snarling in front of the screen.